MAC Creme Cup

I'm baaack, I just can't stay away ;). So I went back to MAC today to get a liner for my Captive gloss, and predictably found myself swatching and "having to get" more. lol. Bad, bad girl!!

I'm going to do one huge haul post later on, but while I was there I asked the girl helping me to try the creme cup on me. I think I like it better with this eye look than Captive! She also tried Dainty Mineralize Blush on me, which I have been eyeing on ebay for a while...for some reason I thought it wasn't available in stores anymore. The two look sooo good!! So I snatched up Dainty, but as far as Creme Cup, she told me I could mix my Viva Glam Gaga and Hue lipsticks to make a similar color. So I saved myself a little money there, right?? ;)

So what do you think? Better with captive and more muted blush, or with Creme Cup and beautiful pink blush??